Morris, Blevins favor assigning letter grades to schoolsPublished 7:20pm Sunday, February 24, 2013
BY JESSICA DAHLBERG/CAPITAL NEWS SERVICE
RICHMOND–Del. Rick Morris, R-Carrollton, and Sen. Harry Blevins, R-Chesapeake, favored legislation that will assign letter grades A to F to Virginia public schools starting in 2014.
Del. Rosalyn Tyler, D-Jarratt, and Sen. Louis Lucas, D-Portsmouth, voted against the legislation passed in General Assembly that will be based on student performance.
The final version of House Bill 1999 was approved Saturday on a 22-17 vote in the Senate and a 65-31 vote in the House. This version had been negotiated through a conference committee of members from both chambers.
One difference between the conference committee’s report and the original draft of HB 1999 involves when the schools will receive their first letter grade.
In the original bill, schools would have been assigned a letter grade by October 2013. The grade would have been based primarily on state accreditation ratings and would not have taken into account students’ educational growth.
Under the adopted version, schools will not be given a grade until October 2014 after the Virginia Board of Education establishes standards to measure student growth.
Students’ academic growth will be based on statewide tests and school test scores. The numbers will be compared with scores from previous year scores and statewide averages.
The Virginia Association of School Superintendents has concerns about the grading system. It takes away the constitutional power of the cities and county governments to manage their own educational systems, said Pat Russo, president-elect of VASS and superintendent of Henrico County Public Schools.
VASS is concerned that if a school gets an F, it will be placed under state authority – usurping local control.
However, Gov. Bob McDonnell believes an A-F grading system will allow for more transparency about the performance of Virginia’s schools. McDonnell received support from two prominent Republicans – Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal and former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush – who had implemented such systems in their states.